Best Italian and Pizza in Sarasota
By Carson B. · Updated November 6, 2026
For pizza, start with Tralia in Gulf Gate, Michelin Recommended for its sourdough and Detroit-style pies, then V&Co Pizzeria and Percocco's for the Northeast style. For a sit-down Italian night, try Vino Vino, Marcello, or La Dolce Vita.
Pizza
Tralia is the one Michelin singled out, calling its pies among the city's best. V&Co Pizzeria at Fruitville Commons makes its sausage in-house. Percocco's in Lakewood Ranch is a Scoop Pick for New Jersey-quality pies, Bavaro's on Fletcher does Neapolitan, and Maestrale on the South Trail is known for pizza and pasta alike.
South Trail's authentic Italian with renowned pizza and pasta
An Italian night out
Marcello is chef-owned and romantic with a changing menu. La Dolce Vita has Gambero Rosso recognition, and Vino Vino on Siesta Drive is family-owned. Sardinia on the South Trail cooks the island's traditions, and La Mucca Ballerina holds down Main Street.
Romantic Italian dining with chef-owner passion and changing menu
Authentic family-owned Italian restaurant serving traditional flavors
On the islands and to the south
Cafe Gabbiano sits steps from Siesta's sand. Nōnnō Umberto is the family Italian on St. Armands, La Norma brings Sicilian hospitality to Longboat Key, and Cassariano and San Marco cover Venice Avenue.
Family Italian on St. Armands — pasta, pizza, prime steaks
Questions
What's the best pizza in Sarasota?
Tralia in Gulf Gate has the Michelin recognition. V&Co Pizzeria and Percocco's are strong picks if you want the Northeast style.
Where's a romantic Italian restaurant in Sarasota?
Marcello on the South Trail and Cafe Gabbiano on Siesta Key are good places to start.